Free the news
ThinkPol
Economy

Inflation has tracked Bank of Canada's high-oil scenario, one that called for repeated rate hikes, deputy governor says

By ThinkPol · · 3 min read

A fuel nozzle in a car's tank, with a Canadian flag on the fuel door
Dreamstime

Inflation has followed the Bank of Canada's "what if oil stays high" scenario from April more closely than its main forecast, Deputy Governor Toni Gravelle said Wednesday. In that scenario, inflation stays near 3 per cent for more than a year and the Bank has to raise interest rates several times in a row.

Gravelle made the point in a speech to the Edmonton Chamber of Commerce on how the central bank talks about an uncertain future. He did not say what the Bank will do at its next rate decision. But the example he chose to illustrate the Bank's use of scenarios was one in which the risk it had flagged has, in his words, "largely materialized."

The oil scenario that came true

In April, about two months into the war in the Middle East, oil was trading around US$100 a barrel. The Bank's base case assumed prices would fall to about $75 by mid-2027, which would bring inflation back to the 2 per cent target early that year.

Because it could not know how long the war would last, the Bank also published a scenario in which oil prices did not come down. In that case, inflation stays close to 3 per cent for more than a year and "consecutive policy rate increases are needed to get inflation back to target," Gravelle said.

By the Bank's October decision, six months later, the war had not ended and oil was still near $100. Refinery margins were above historical norms, pushing fuel prices up further, and new U.S. tariffs were adding uncertainty, though the economy was doing better than the Bank had expected. "Oil prices and inflation, meanwhile, had tracked the higher-for-longer April scenario more closely than the base case," Gravelle said. "In other words, the upside risk to inflation we had identified in April had largely materialized."

Why the Bank publishes "what-if" scenarios

Most of the speech was a defence of the Bank's growing use of published scenarios. Gravelle said the Bank has always run them internally but now publishes them more often because "we're living in a more shock-prone world": a pandemic, an inflation surge, wars in Europe and the Middle East, an energy price shock and a trade conflict that "has hit Canada particularly hard."

He gave three examples:

  • The pandemic. In April 2020, uncertainty was so extreme that the Bank published only a range of scenarios instead of a single forecast. Gravelle said it would only do that again in similar conditions.
  • A wage-price spiral. In July 2022, the Bank published a scenario in which businesses and workers kept raising prices and wages because they expected high inflation to continue. Breaking that cycle required much higher rates and a deep recession, as in the early 1980s. It did not happen, but Gravelle said the scenario helped explain why the Bank raised rates so forcefully.
  • High oil prices, the April 2026 scenario that inflation has since tracked.

Gravelle said the Bank does not publish every scenario it runs, because too many could confuse people about which risks matter most and distract from the main forecast.

The risk of saying too much

Gravelle also addressed a long-running debate among central banks over "forward guidance," signals about where interest rates are headed. Clear guidance helps markets anticipate decisions, but if investors lean on it too much, they "stop doing their homework" and stop reacting to new data. Central banks then lose an independent read on how investors see the economy. Gravelle cited his own 2010 research with Chris Fay, which found that markets responded less to new economic data during periods when the Bank's press releases included forward guidance.

Scenarios, he argued, help by making clear that guidance describes "not necessarily what will happen, but rather what could happen."

He tied the approach to the Bank's independence and accountability. The Bank and the federal government renewed the 2 per cent inflation target on Nov. 5, in an agreement that runs to the end of 2031. "Credibility isn't about always being right," Gravelle said. "It's about being transparent about our thinking and showing that, no matter what happens, we remain focused on achieving our objective."

Source: Toni Gravelle, "Setting the scenario: Monetary policy communications in uncertain times," speech to the Edmonton Chamber of Commerce, Bank of Canada, Nov. 18, 2026.

Front PageEconomy#Bank of Canada#Toni Gravelle#Inflation#Interest rates#Oil prices#Monetary policy