Opinion: The brokers who sell Vancouver's rental buildings don't want renters to have more rights

When the people who earn commissions selling apartment buildings say a tenant protection will "hurt renters," it is fair to ask whose interests they are protecting.
On Monday, Daily Hive ran an opinion piece by Mark Goodman, Ian Brackett and Megan Johal, brokers at Goodman Commercial. In their own description, the firm specializes in "the sale of rental apartment buildings and development sites in Metro Vancouver." They were writing about COPE Coun. Sean Orr's motion for a Universal Tenant Rights By-law, which they called a "governmental sledgehammer" that "could crush housing investment in the city."
That is a lot of alarm over a motion that asks staff for a report.
What the motion actually does
Orr's motion goes to council's Standing Committee on City Finance and Services on Wednesday, and it does not enact anything. It directs staff to report back by the end of the first quarter of 2027 with a standalone tenant protection bylaw. The motion lists eight items for that bylaw: universal vacancy control, a right of return with "like for like" replacement units, developer-funded bridge housing, a proactive inspection and repair mandate, an elected or randomly selected tenant oversight board, legal recognition of tenant unions, a "fit and proper" test for landlords, and a public registry of "cash for keys" buyout offers. It also asks staff to fold these points, "where applicable," into the city's upcoming review of its Tenant Relocation and Protection Policy. Council would then debate what staff bring back, along with legal advice on what the city can and cannot do.
The motion's full title promises to "Criminalize Predatory Practices." The brokers are right that a city cannot create crimes, and that wording overreaches. But a headline is not a bylaw, and nothing in the eight items requires criminal law.
That is how policy is supposed to be made. The brokers would rather council not ask the question at all. They want Mayor Pete Fry to deliver "a firm rebuke" to his own deputy mayor to reassure what they call "the investment community." Vancouver did not elect a council to manage the mood of people who buy apartment buildings.
"Unserious" on jurisdiction? Ask the SRO owners
The brokers write that "it's obvious on jurisdictional issues alone that Orr is unserious." It is not obvious, and the city's own recent history shows why.
In 2021, Vancouver passed vacancy control for single-room occupancy hotels, which limited how much rent could rise when a room changed tenants. SRO owners sued, and the courts ruled that the city had exceeded its authority. The province then amended the law at the city's request, and in 2024 council re-enacted the rules. Vancouver's powers come from the Vancouver Charter, which Victoria can change and has changed. A city asking for powers it does not yet have is not a joke. It is how Vancouver got many of the powers it uses today.
Nor is the motion vague about where its powers would come from. It proposes the "fit and proper" test under section 272 of the Vancouver Charter, the city's existing business-licensing power. It points to the tenant protection bylaws in Toronto, Montreal, New York, San Francisco and, across the inlet, the District of North Vancouver.
The other ideas the brokers treat as fringe are already in use elsewhere. Toronto's RentSafeTO program already inspects apartment buildings and orders repairs. Montreal uses a right of first refusal to buy buildings for social housing. Since 2006, Scotland has required landlords to pass a "fit and proper person" test before they can register to rent out property. Neither place has run out of landlords.
The brokers' own argument works against them
The most revealing part of the piece is how it describes today's market. Vancouver, the brokers write, is in "a rare period of oversupply." Tenants have "an unusual amount of choice" and "an uncommon ability to negotiate terms." When there is enough housing, they say, "tenants gain leverage without the need for punitive policy."
Then they predict: "these conditions won't last."
Put those two claims together. Under B.C.'s Residential Tenancy Act, rent increases are capped while a tenant stays, but the rent can be reset to any amount when a unit changes hands. That gap is what drives renovictions and buyout offers: every departure is a chance to reset the rent. Closing it costs landlords almost nothing while they are competing for tenants, because the market will not bear big increases anyway. Vacancy control only starts to matter when the market tightens again, which is exactly what the brokers say is coming.
So they are not defending today's rents. They are defending the ability to raise rents sharply once renters lose their leverage. That future rent growth is part of what a buyer pays for when buying an apartment building, and a broker's commission is a share of that price.
Private capital has had plenty of public help
"Vancouver needs private capital to build, hold, and maintain enough rental housing," the brokers write. "No level of government can replace it."
Much of the new rental housing behind today's oversupply was built with public help. Ottawa's Apartment Construction Loan Program, formerly the Rental Construction Financing Initiative, gives developers low-cost federal loans for purpose-built rentals. CMHC's MLI Select insurance lets them borrow more on easier terms in exchange for affordability commitments. In 2023, the federal government removed the GST from new purpose-built rental construction. Vancouver has also waived development cost levies for qualifying rental projects.
Investors are welcome to that help. But an industry that relies on federal loans, federal tax breaks and city fee waivers is in no position to tell the public it may not attach conditions.
Who pays when buildings rot
The brokers count "City-mandated repairs" among the motion's worst features, as if a repair order were an attack on property. Vancouver has seen what happens when repairs go undone. The Balmoral and Regent hotels on the Downtown Eastside declined for years despite repeated city orders, until the city shut them as unsafe and moved to expropriate them. Taxpayers are now paying for what the owners would not.
Proactive inspection exists so renters do not have to wait for the ceiling to come down before anyone acts. It costs extra only for landlords who were not maintaining their buildings to begin with.
Blaming tenants for the credit cycle
The brokers point out that developers are cancelling approved projects "because the numbers no longer pencil." That is true, but none of those numbers has anything to do with Orr's motion, which has not even been voted on. Projects are stalling because of interest rates, construction costs, slower population growth and softer rents, the same oversupply the brokers praised a few paragraphs earlier. Adding a motion that has not passed to that list makes renters the scapegoat for a downturn they did not cause.
The brokers end by saying that "the strongest protection a tenant can have is choice." By their own account, tenants have had a good year for choice, and the brokers expect it to end. Renters who remember the last time the market turned, with its renovictions, bidding wars over one-bedrooms and buyout offers, have good reason to want protections that last longer than a soft patch in the rental cycle.
Whether Orr's specific proposals survive staff review, legal advice and council debate is a fair question. Whether council should drop them before it has even asked, on the advice of people whose income depends on what investors will pay for Vancouver's apartment buildings, is not.
Rohana Rezel is a technologist, researcher, and community leader based in Vancouver, BC.