Listen to Canadians before reforming Bill C-51, joint open letter urges Trudeau
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau needs to listen to Canadians before bringing forward a reform package on Bill C-51, according to a joint open letter penned by a broad range of civil society groups and privacy experts, who say Canadians need to be fully consulted if C-51 is to be effectively addressed.
The letter also calls on Trudeau, whose Liberals with the Conservatives to pass the legislation, to state whether there are parts of C-51 he wants to keep, his justification for doing so, and a clear articulation of how this will impact our rights and freedoms.
The groups say that in light of last week’s tragic events in Paris and Beirut, it’s more important than ever to strike the right balance between effective security legislation and upholding Canadian democratic values.
Warning that Bill C-51 poses “a direct and ongoing threat to Canadian innovation, political discourse, freedom of expression, privacy, and civil liberties,” the letter points out that Canadians have never been meaningfully consulted on the bill.
“Listen before you leap – that’s our message to Justin Trudeau,” explained OpenMedia’s digital rights specialist Laura Tribe. “The previous government did everything it could to sideline Canadians from the C-51 debate. It’s time to change that by giving every Canadian a say, and there’s no better place to start than by launching a full public consultation. C-51 is now the law of the land, undermining our rights each day that goes by. We don’t have a moment to lose.”
“We are happy that the new government has committed to both fix the problems in C-51 and to make its decisions based on evidence,” said Josh Paterson, Executive Director of the B.C. Civil Liberties Association. “No real evidence was provided by the last government that Bill C-51’s rights-violating measures make us any safer, and numerous experts have made clear that the law makes it harder to protect the public. We are counting on the government to lead Canadians in taking a deep and serious look at how C-51 got it wrong and how national security law can be made right.”
“Given the sweeping breadth of former Bill C-51’s rights infringing impact, any attempt to properly and effectively prevent the harms it will inflict on Canadian society must be informed by a comprehensive public consultation,” Tamir Israel, Staff Lawyer with the Canadian Internet Policy and Public Interest Clinic, said. “This is a must. Such a consultation can only hope to succeed, however, if the government first explains to the public what changes it is making to the provisions enacted by Bill C-51, what elements are being kept, and most importantly, why. The case for Bill C-51 has simply never been made to the public, and it must.”
Trudeau has indicated that he sees reforming Bill C-51 as a top priority, and potential reforms to the controversial legislation have already been floated in the media, but the government has given no indication as to whether or how it plans to consult Canadians on its proposals.
The letter sets out a suggested 3-step process for effective public consultation:
- Government Position Statement: a public explanation of the government’s rationale for C-51, including an assessment of the impact on civil liberties and an explanation for why these are justified.
- Public Consultations: a national online consultation process to ensure all Canadians can have their voices heard and acted on before new legislation is tabled.
- Consultations with experts and stakeholders: a public consultation with civil society groups, academics, businesses, and other stakeholders on the basis of the Government’s position statement and plans to move forward.
In the last week, over 10,000 people have emailed Justin Trudeau asking him to meet with Canadians before introducing reforms, and to date, over 300,000 people have signed a petition calling for Bill C-51 to be completely repealed.
Organizations signing the joint letter are:
B.C. Freedom of Information and Privacy Association, British Columbia Civil Liberties Association, Canadian Access and Privacy Association, Canadian Civil Liberties Association, Canadian Internet Policy & Public Interest Clinic (CIPPIC), Canadian Journalists for Free Expression (CJFE), Canadian Access and Privacy Association, Centre for Free Expression (Ryerson University), Centre for Law and Democracy, Canadian Institute of Access and Privacy Professionals, Council of Canadians, FACIL, Free Dominion, International Civil Liberties Monitoring Group (ICLMG), Keepers of the Water, Leadnow.ca, Ontario Civil Liberties Association, OpenMedia, Privacy and Access Council of Canada, Privacy International, The Student Coalition for Privacy, United Steelworkers, Voices-Voix, Youth Vote Canada.
Experts and academics signing the joint letter are:
Ann Cavoukian (Privacy and Big Data Institute, Ryerson University), Benjamin J. Muller (Associate Professor, Department of Political Science, University of Western Ontario), Dr. Christopher Parsons (Managing Director of the Telecom Transparency Project at Citizen Lab, Munk School of Global Affairs), Colin J. Bennett (Professor of Political Science, University of Victoria), David Murakami Wood, (Canada Research Chair in Surveillance Studies), Dr. Jennifer Barrigar (Privacy Research and Policy Analysis), Dr. Leslie Regan Shade (Associate Professor, Faculty of Information, University of Toronto), Ken Rubin (Investigative researcher), Kevin McArthur (Security Researcher and Elected Director in Internet Governance), Stephanie Perrin (President, Digital Discretion), Andrew Clement (Professor Emeritus, Faculty of Information, University of Toronto), John Wunderlich (Privacy Researcher), Dr. Valerie Steeves (Associate Professor, Department of Criminology, University of Ottawa).